For example, the classic procedure involves asking participants to rate paintings made by two artists. Article pdf available in personality and social psychology bulletin 2212. Predictions from the bounded and unbounded reciprocity hypotheses and from social identity theory sit were examined in a minimal group experiment in which ingroup outcome dependence, outgroup outcome dependence, and the strength of social identity were orthogonally manipulated. A participant was not allowed to award money to himself.
Consequences of minimal group affiliations in children. The socalled minimal group studies show that people tend to favor their own group in terms of reward allocations even when they are categorized on a trivial basis e. Ingroup bias in the minimal group paradigm shown by. In the nongroup control, subjects allocate income to themselves and to a random participant in the experiment. Discrimination in the minimal group paradigm 79 44 36 34 34 36 44 30 47 22 42 table 1 ingroup and outgroup outcomes as a function of the multiple alternative matrices allocation strategy max max max max rel max joint min joint max rel recipient own own own dif other other other ingroup 42 47 outgroup 22 30 note. The minimal group paradigm this activity replicates, more or less, the exact experiment used by henri tajfel to demonstrate the minimal group paradigm used in social identity theory. The three additional states are referred to as colortriplet higgs scalars. That is, the minimal group treatment can uncover individual tendencies. The minimal polynomial of ais the least common multiple of all the elementary divisors. The paradigm was set up to challenge the notion of intergroup conflict or ingroup favouritism and discover the minimal conditions for intergroup behaviour, that is, those conditions which are both necessary and sufficient for a collection of individuals to be ethnocentric i. Intergroup discrimination and selfesteem in the minimal. Minimal group procedures 5 illuminating the advantages and disadvantages of the matrices e. The initial minimal group paradigm mgp experiments billig.
On the measurement of social orientations in the minimal. The minimal group paradigm developed by tajfel and associates e. The tajfel matrices have been criticized for confounding the different allocation strategies brewer. Study 1 employed the thinkaloud procedure in the minimal group paradigm mgp and concludes that social categorization is insufficient to cause social identity or intergroup discrimination, and that no theoretical explanation of minimal group behaviour is adequate to explain the variety of strategies employed within that paradigm. This article details a registered report for a wellpowered n 1500 experiment examining the influence of wealth inequality between groups on ingroup bias, as well as the potential moderating role of justification for the wealth distribution. Tajfel matrices were used to provide a variety of options for point allocation and the choices made by participants were thus the key measure of ingroup. In this condition, participants were informed that their behaviour on the matrices could affect how subsequent positive and negative tasks would be allocated. There is a need therefore to revisit these studies in an environment that captures the interactive nature of groups and illuminates the diachronic processes involved in group formation and behaviour. The numbers in the matrices shown below represent units of 110 of a penny. Pdf social identity theory sit proposes that discrimination reflects competition. Like any good experimentalist, tajfel sought a flexible procedure within which to manipulate features thought to relate to the formation of intergroup bias.
The minimal group paradigm is widely used in social psychology to study the most basic. Outgroup accountability in the minimal group paradigm citeseerx. In a typical minimal group paradigm experiment, participants are randomly allocated to a group and then asked to concurrently distribute resources to ingroup and outgroup members on allocation matrices specifically designed to measure allocation strategies that favor the ingroup and. Subjective uncertainty and intergroup discrimination in. That is, they will assume that this piece of information is relevant for the current topic of the experimentinteraction in this case, working on the matrices. The minimal group paradigm and its maximal impact in research on social categorization. Psychology with shahroze suzuki recommended for you. Students receive a handout with matrices listing different values that their side of the auditorium the ingroup would. The minimal group paradigm mgp is a popular method of testing intergroup.
Contrary to most other research conducted in the minimal group paradigm tradition, bornstein, crum, wittenbraker, harring, insko and thibaut 1983a found little evidence of ingroup favoritism when they employed a revised measurement system i. Tajfel matrices, has subjects distribute money to ingroup and outgroup. The minimal group paradigm is a methodology employed in social psychology. In one condition the top row of the matrices represented the amounts that could be allocated to a fellow group member. Generate ordered matrices, each of which should consist of 14 boxes containing two numbers. Conversation logic effects in the minimal group paradigm. Controversy regarding the tajfel matrices prompted the creation of an alternative. Intergroup behavior has long been studied within and among various societies. One of the most influential paradigms in research on intergroup relations is the minimal group paradigm. Minimal group paradigm definition the minimal group paradigm is a procedure that researchers use to create new social groups in the laboratory.
Chen and li 2009 use a minimal group paradigm and study average social preferences towards ingroup and outgroup members. Based on this premise, we investigated whether ingroup favouritism within the minimal group paradigm is reduced to the extent that individuals possess autistic traits. Categorization versus noncategorization x matrix task. The goal is to categorize individuals into groups based on minimal criteria that are relatively trivial or arbitrary. Pdf the minimal group paradigm and the tajfel matricesfundamental orientations in resource allocationspsychological and. For example, much work has demonstrated the power of the minimal group paradigm a research method to determine the minimal conditions needed for discriminatory behavior to promote an ingroup. For example, much work has demonstrated the power of the minimal group paradigm a research method to determine the minimal conditions needed for discriminatory behavior to promote an in group. Using the minimal group paradigm, in which participants are assigned to groups with anonymous others and asked to allocate resources to ingroup or. Minimal group paradigm study experiments henri tajfel. Website software copyright 2019, archieboy holdings, llc. Studying the effects of status in an interactive minimal. Although this makes sense in the context of intergroup comparisons, selfesteem may, of course, be affected in other ways.
Maximum joint profit and giving the largest reward to the ingroup would both be achieved by choosing the last pair in the row, giving 19 to a member of your own group, and 25 to a member of the other group. If px is any polynomial satisfying pa 0, then pis divisible by m a as a. Although it may be used for a variety of purposes, it is most well known as a method for investigating the minimal conditions required for discrimination to occur between groups. Studies in the social psychology of intergroup relations pp.
Intergroup discrimination in the minimal group paradigm. Using the classic minimal group paradigm, participants were randomly assigned to minimal groups before completing the task to allocate points to one of their fellow in or outgroup members. However, research has also shown that conflicts of interests and selfinterest motives may not even be necessary for ingroup bias to occur. This paradigm, where a number of assumptions, concepts, values or practices were accepted in order to better allow a view of reality in relation to the onset of human group. Tajfel to demonstrate the minimal group paradigm used in social identity theory. Using the minimal group paradigm, 94 undergraduates were randomly. On equating social identity with arbitrary group membership. Minimal group research began when henri tajfel sought to develop a basic paradigm within which to study the origins of intergroup bias tajfel, 19712001. Minimal group procedures 3 an improved and deceptionfree minimal group induction procedure many years ago, a laboratory experiment produced curious findings. The minimal group paradigm have received widespread attention and stimulated has been greatly influential in the area of inter recent theoretical developments of intergroup rela group relations particularly in its formulation of tions and prejudice cf. The minimal group paradigm has been used in various study fields otten, 2016, and was first presented by tajfel and colleagues 1970tajfel and colleagues, 1971tajfel and colleagues, 1974. Smith university of british columbia, vancouver, canada this experiment was designed to test the hypothesis that intergroup discrimination in the minimal group paradigm is related to selfesteem.
Tajfel experiments 1970 harry potter edition duration. Initially motivated by an interest in understanding the basic determinants of social discrimination, this paradigm investigates the impact of social categorization on intergroup relations in the absence of realistic conflicts of interests, and for social categories that are arbitrary and novel. The minimal group paradigm and its minimal psychology. Minimal group paradigm definition psychology glossary. There is a unique monic polynomial m ax of minimal degree such that m aa 0. Initial evidence for this was provided when yamagishi et al. Social categorization and social discrimination in the minimal group paradigm. Ingroup bias in the minimal group paradigm shown by three. In the minimal group treatment, subjects are divided into two groups according to answers to a questionnaire on preferences for lines of poetry, paintings, and. From the start, most au thors approached the problem on a kinematic level, i. The pauli group performing this action is in general a ddit but is a 2qutrit 2qt for the group 120,5 sl2,5 2i, a. The present study combines both methods, where the minimal group treatment serves as a control for the political group treatment.
Students receive a handout with matrices listing different values that their side of the auditorium the ingroup would receive and that the other side the out. However, to maximise your own rewards while also maximising the difference, you might well choose one of the middle boxes and give 12 to a member of your own group and 11 to a member of. Intergroup discrimination and selfesteem in the minimal group paradigm louise lemyre and philip m. The bottom row referred to amounts available for allocation to another member of the ingroup. The effects of mortality salience on intergroup bias.
The minimal group paradigm and its maximal impact in. The minimal group paradigm is a methodology employed in social psychology to investigate the minimal conditions required for discrimination to occur between groups. We designed the present experiment to test the hypothesis that ms would intensify intergroup bias in minimal. Knowing the minimal polynomial of a matrix often leaves only a few possibilities for the elementary divisors. Pdf social orientations in the minimal group paradigm. Ingroup bias found in the minimal group paradigm is an important finding for. Minimal group paradigm is a social psychology research methodology that proposes that the minimal condition for group biases like favoritism towards your own group and prejudice towards other groups is simply being a member of a group.
1276 1308 592 464 1194 1420 651 711 1497 347 858 42 1290 426 243 890 256 850 540 38 1450 177 537 825 214 1043 600 1174 XML HTML